Concrete Road Vs Asphalt Road – Which is Better?

Concrete Road Vs Asphalt Road

The terms “Bitumen” and “Asphalt” are regularly used correspondingly to mean both natural and manufactured forms of the material.

Before discussing the difference between Concrete Road and Asphalt Road, we first need to understand what asphalt is and how it differs from bitumen.

What is Bitumen?

Bitumen is the binding agent produced residue from petroleum distillation or obtained naturally.

What is Asphalt?

Whereas asphalt is a mixture of black, sticky, viscous hydrocarbon material, coarse and fine aggregate produced in the plant. This composite mix is also known as asphalt concrete.

So let us discuss the differences between Concrete Road and Asphalt Roads. 

Durability

Concrete roads are more durable than asphalt roads, whereas asphalt roads are less durable than concrete roads.

Effect of Weather

With varying water table levels and varying rainfall conditions across the Indian geography concrete road emerged as a more durable and sturdy option. 

Since asphalt roads are known to get eroded by water, whereas heavy rain and other extreme weather conditions damage the asphalt road, and the road needs to be repaired frequently. 

Construction Speed

Construction of concrete roads requires machinery such as concrete paving machine batching plant or concrete mixture, transit mixture, etc. Also, concrete takes more time for curing, and hence the speed of the construction is less compared to asphalt roads. 

Whereas it takes less time to lay an asphalt road than a concrete road, there is no need to carry huge machines like the concrete mixture. 

Concrete Road Vs Asphalt Road

Resistance to Skid

In the rainy and winter season, vehicles tend to slip or slide on the concrete road due to rain and snow.

In comparison, asphalt roads increase road safety. They are skid resistance with better traction. There are fewer chances of accidents. 

Tyre Noise 

Concrete roads can be noisier because it is necessary during the construction to make it rough enough to provide a tyre grip.

However, it must be noted that the cause of the noise is not the concrete itself but the texture of concrete roads. It has been observed that transverse grooving result in a higher noise level and longitudinal grooving may help to reduce the noise level.

On the other hand, asphalt road provides a smoother and often quieter ride when relatively new.

Deflection

In the concrete road, the vehicle loads are transferred to subbase soil by the flexural strength of the pavement, and the entire pavement acts as a rigid plate. Dowel bars are provided at intervals so that there is no deflection of the slab due to the vehicle load. 

In the case of asphalt road, the vehicle load is transferred grain to grain through the aggregates’ contact through the granular structure. Hence, during the rainy season, these roads are prone to seepage of water and potholes are formed due to continuous movement of traffic on all these roads.

Effect of Oil

Concrete roads do not get damaged by the leaking oil from the vehicle, whereas oil leaks can damage the asphalt roads.

Fuel Consumption

As per a study conducted by Central Road Research Institute, the commercial vehicle may save up to 14% fuel with the run on the concrete roads. It is because the concrete road does not get deflected Under The Wheels of a loaded truck. 

Whereas in the case of asphalt roads there is no such saving on fuel. 

Ease of Repair

Concrete roads do not require frequent repair for patching work like Asphalt roads, but if the concrete road break, the whole corporate slab needs to be replaced.

On the other hand, asphalt is a cheaper and faster solution for short-term projects. Still, the repairs are sometimes just as extensive as concrete roads, with only ten years of life span. Asphalt must be relaid or repaired on a much more regulars basis.

Concrete Road Vs Asphalt Road

Maintenance 

Concrete roads are maintenance-free, or we can say they require very minimum maintenance if they laid properly.

In contrast, maintenance of asphalt road is easy. If part of the road is damaged, then it can be easily repaired, even it can be easily re-layered over the old layer.

Pollution

Concerning pollution, concrete is a better alternative than asphalt because its production generates less environmental pollution. It is also produced from readily available limestone. Also, cars run on the concrete road provides better fuel efficiency.

Asphalt produces lots of highly polluting gases at the time of melting it for paving also Petroleum is required to produce asphalt, which is an expensive product.

Life-Span

It is estimated that good quality concrete road can sustain for 40 years, whereas asphalt roads are last for around ten years. 

Cost 

Based on the initial cost of pavement, concrete roads are reported to be over 20% costlier than the asphalt roads. However, your life cycle cost basis concrete roads are estimated to be around 20 to 25% cheaper than asphalt roads. 

Whereas asphalt is still less costly as compared to concrete. Asphalt dries faster hence it takes less time to build asphalt road than a concrete road.

Conclusion

Concrete roads can be a feasible option in areas where the weather conditions are adverse. And asphalt is ideal for rural roadways because of low traffic, ease of maintenance and repair. 

The ministry of road transport and Highways, Government of India has decided to construct the national highway in cement concrete as a default option. 

Even they are more than 20% costlier. However, on life cycle cost basis concrete roads due to their long life for 30 to 40 years and high durability concrete roads are estimated to be around 20 to 25% cheaper than asphalt roads.

Thus on a long-term basis, concrete roads are the most economical choice for pavement which provide long useful life.

Also, read

What is WBM Road? Construction Procedure, Advantages and Disadvantages

Material Required For Construction of WBM Road

Leave a Comment

More in Transportation Engineering
What is Road Gradient?
What is Road Gradient? – Definition and Types

What is Road Gradient? It is the rate of rise...

Close